From the category archives:

helping people

I don’t do well with unsolicited advice. Maybe because I grew up with a control-freak, who told me how I should do everything (and still does), even when I’m already doing it and I have been doing it and I know how to do it, damn it.

Maybe because I know that we don’t all think alike, and that there are some things people feel really strongly about – which means when you start a discussions with people you don’t know about some very specific topics, you can end up with an open can and worms everywhere.

Maybe because I feel that giving advice the other person didn’t ask for is a bit patronizing. Because I know that sometimes people just want to vent, don’t want your input – in other words, they just want you to lend them an ear, not a blabbing mouth.

Of course, I am not without sin in this. I will sometimes break the rule and offer advice. But if the person didn’t ask for it explicitly, I make it short and to the point and put it as “this is my experience” as opposed as “this is what you should do”. And generally, when talking to a friend who is just unloading and venting, I ask her: “would you like my input on this, or do you just need to get it off your chest?” or something along those lines.

Sharing things online means you have to be willing to get input you may not want, or like. And we are all comment wh*res, we all love getting replies to our tweets and comments to our posts, because that’s what interaction is, right?

So when a tweet from me expressing frustration over people whining about a certain thing and not knowing how good they have it spurred a parenting lesson from another (well-meaning, I’m sure) tweeter, one that included book titles and that extended for 3 tweets (which would have been more had I let it go further, I’m sure) I found myself in the position of having to choose between lie between my teeth and say “oh, wow, thank you for the valuable info, I had no idea”, ignore the tweets and risk to have more coming my way (which probably would have annoyed me more) or just say “don’t take it the wrong way, but I wasn’t really looking for advice on this” which sounds rude, even though it doesn’t mean to be… but at least it’s the truth. And that’s actually what I did, risking to come a cross as a completely unfriendly, bitchy, ungrateful little brat.

Then of course, because I am constantly second-guessing myself, I was tempted to send an apology and explanation her way. Then I thought maybe she’d understand and leave it at that. But it was obvious from subsequent tweets that she was offended. So I did send the slightly apologetic, explanatory tweets after all.

And then, I sent one that pretty much summarizes how I feel about this type of thing:

signature-shoeplate3b

{ 4 comments }

Lean on me. I think.

by Elisa on May 8, 2009

in friends,helping people

We live in the real world. It’s no fairy tale. In real life, sometimes things get tough. And sometimes when things get tough we take it out on the wrong person, lash out at someone we like and care for. And sometimes, we are that someone. We are the ones being used as scape goat, the one to blame for someone’s troubles, for their hard times.

Tonight I was that someone. Unexpectedly, shockingly, I found myself the target of harsh accusations, of a one-way screaming match, of mean words and the worst possible complaint, the one you never want to hear coming from a friend’s mouth, someone you care for: “You don’t give a damn about me.”

That’s a tough thing to digest – especially so when it comes from someone we were trying to help. My first reaction: second guessing myself. Was it true? Could I have done more? Could I have done better? Were my efforts totally useless? Was my attempt to help unsuccessful and pointless?

I am my own worst critic. I tend to second-guess myself, and I often find myself at fault – I can always do more, help more, go one step further. And like most Italian (and Latin in general, I believe) women, I kind of have a “mom complex”. I want to take care of people, and I never feel like I am doing enough or just as much as I should. And yet, this time, a little voice in the back of my head said “Even if that was true, even if your efforts didn’t pan out, your support should still count for something. You don’t deserve this.” What? Me, in defense of me? Never happens. Must be a mistake.

After the upset, another followed, a private one. I literally could  not stop crying. I wasn’t crying because  felt sorry for myself, I was crying because I felt sad, ’cause this wasn’t just a fight, it was the end of a relationship. No going back from here.

And I felt bad, guilty. I had quickly shushed that little voice that was coming in my defense, and I was back to the accusations, which rang in my ears and echoed in my head. I’m a bad friend. Tears. I let my friend down. More tears, a sea of tears. Hard to stop now. Thank goodness the girls can’t see me, they would get very upset. Sarah will have bad dreams. How am I going to put them to bed? I have to stop crying. But I couldn’t. For the first time in a long time, I coulnd’t stop crying. And I felt stupid and pathetic and whiny, which only made me mad and caused tears of anger, which together with the tears of guilt, of self-doubt, was now making it really, really hard to do anything but cry.

I have to talk to someone. But I can’t. I don’t want to badmouth my friend. Inevitably, when someone is crying, you tend to take their side a little bit already from the start. I felt that was unfair. After all, I was the one who did a poor job at helping my friend. Her outburst, no matter how harsh, was caused my my not being up to the task. I hadn’t been the friend she needed.

Maybe I can tweet. Just one tweet, no reference to anyone or anything specific. It could be even rhetorical. But at least a little outlet. For the girls. So I can take care of them. If Sascha was here, I could tell him I need a moment and he could take care of them, but he won’t get back until tomorrow. So I did. Just one little tweet. No one is probably even going to reply now, especially not to such a banal, cliché line. But someone did. A friend, who should have been having dinner with her family in peace, who had just ended a very busy day and yet had offered to help with something already. A friend who promptly called and didn’t mind me being a blubbering mess, didn’t judge me as harshly as I was judging myself, didn’t seem to think less of me for being miserable and heartbroken. A friend who said all the right things, all the things I already knew, but needed to hear. A friend who gave me a virtual hug, when I needed it most and I didn’t have the courage to ask. A friend who didn’t let me go until she could hear in my voice that I was better, that I was going to be ok.

And I am. Ok, that is. Heartbroken, too – still. It’s a fresh wound, but it’ll heal in time. Heartbreak happens. This is real life, after all.

signature-shoeplate3b

{ 3 comments }

Copyright Elisa Bieg, 2008-2009.