Silence is golden. Or maybe it’s made of Swiss chocolate.

by Elisa on March 16, 2010

in highlights,Switzerland,The X-pat Files

“The problem is that people are encouraged to function as machines. Or actually, as mechanisms. Human emotion and sympathy are unprofessional. They are inappropriate to the exercise of reason.”

[...]

“We have lots of cake. But no revolutionaries. Revolution, the shouting and breaking things. It’s very un-Swiss.”

from The Gone-Away World by Nick Harkaway*

The Swiss are very tidy. They are very orderly, very organized, very private, and really friggin’ quiet. Me, I’m Italian. I am messy. I am not reserved. In fact, like most Italians, I may even border on the “too friendly” side of things. And not in a million years would anyone in their right mind ever use the word “quiet” when referring to me. I talk just a tad too loud. I laugh too laud, too – I’m sorry, but in a moment of hilarity, I am just not one of those people who can put a hand in front of their mouth (unless I’m chewing, of course) and stifle a girlish giggle, then just smile. When I laugh, I embrace it, damn it.

This often makes me conspicuous here. Mind you, it’s not like I’m a spy or a ninja, I don’t set out to just blend into the background, but I don’t purposely make a show of myself, either. It’s just, you know, stuff happens.


Imagine being at dinner with friends. Friends by extension, because they were friends of your husband’s before you two even met… but still, friends. After an initial lull, the conversation seems to, if not exactly flow, at least progress fairly smoothly. You start to relax. You don’t have to watch your every step here, you tell yourself. These are friends. You like them, they like you. Just chill. Enjoy the evening. So you do. Everyone is conversing amiably, and eating (but not at the same time, because that would be gross.) Then all of a sudden the conversation stops. There is a long, awkward pause. What just happened?? You look around: no one spilled their wine,  no one dropped an expensive plate on the floor. You replay the last few seconds in your head: who was the last person to say something? damn, it was you. But try as you might, you cannot imagine what you could have said that would warrant such a reaction. Long after your husband cleared his voice and broke the silence with a Would anyone like more wine? you sit, bewildered. Whatever your faux-pas was, you know it will be politely ignored – though mind you, not forgotten. Committing hara-kiri with your fondue fork sounds pretty good right about now.

On the tram. A young mother gets on with her newborn. It’s one of the older trams, the ones with the stairs. A man helps the young mom lift the pram onto the tram, then steps away without saying anything. The mom tries to maneuver the pram so that she isn’t blocking access onto or off the tram for other passengers, and some people standing nearby unwillingly move to make space. Some just stand right where they are and keep reading their newspaper. No one stops to look at the cute baby, sleeping in the pram. The mom, after apologizing profusely to anyone who might have had to move to make space for her and her baby, starts to relax a bit. But not completely. She is silently begging her baby not to wake up, not to make a peep until it’s time to get off. Because she remembers clearly what it felt like to break the complete silence of the tram; she remembers the disapproving glances from fellow passengers, and how she got off a couple of stops too early because she couldn’t bear feeling uncomfortable and embarrassed for 5 more minutes.

On the tram. My cell phone rings. I look around to see if there are any signs showing cell phones as verboten (loud, obnoxious, devilish objects, cell phones) and upon making sure there aren’t any, I pick up. It’s my godmother, wishing me a Happy Birthday. I smile, thank her, and then we start talking. I laugh sometimes, but I try to keep my voice down, because the tram was so quiet before my phone rang. Still, despite my efforts, looks like I am still disturbing the quiet, meditative moment everyone must be enjoying, because a Shhhh! is thrown in my direction like a javelin. No longer trying to keep quiet, I tell my godmother Sorry, I have to let you go, someone on the tram just shushed me. No, I’m not kidding! I laugh. I’ll call you back.

A few minutes later, I get off. As the door opens and I prepare to exit, an old lady turns to me and says, in an accented Italian It’s just that everyone could hear what you were talking about. I smile to her and reply That’s ok, it’s not like I was discussing state secrets. And as I step off the tram I add Buona giornata! and wave. As the doors close behind me and the tram departs, I turn to see her bewildered expression as she watches me from the tram window.

Shortly before our move to New York I started seeing a new tram model around Zurich: the Cobra. The Cobra stays low to the ground, and slithers quietly through the streets of Zurich. It’s easy to board, especially for moms with strollers and people in wheelchairs, and it doesn’t contribute to the noise level in the city, which compared to many other cities outside of Switzerland is still surprisingly low. What some don’t know is that the Cobra was originally made even quieter than that, and had to be modified to be slightly less quiet, so people could hear it coming.

Zurich is a beautiful city. The winter just doesn’t do it justice – even with the Christmas decorations, Zurich is just not at its best in winter. Starting in May, is when you can see it at its best. The Bahnhostrasse buzzing with people, the Hauptbahnhof so much more beautiful when the light shines through the windows and the fountain outside is brought back to life. And the lake, of course. Walking along the Limmatquai, following the river down to Bellevue, and there you are rewarded with one of the best views in Zurich. And when you stop to enjoy the view, when you hesitate to take a photo because you don’t know if it will do justice to the sun sparkling on the water, to the Alps far on the horizon, to the boats and the ducks somehow coexisting peacefully on the smooth surface of the lake… that’s when the quiet doesn’t bother you so much.

* which is a novel, not an essay on politics and socio-economical problems. And these quotes are taken out of context and totally unrelated. Except in my head, where they are clearly not.

Leave a Comment

{ 36 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Alecia @ Hoobing Family Adventures
Twitter:
March 16, 2010 at 5:22 PM

Did you find out what you said at dinner?
.-= Alecia @ Hoobing Family Adventures´s last blog ..Vitamin D in the Form of Yard Work =-.

Reply

2 melissa March 16, 2010 at 5:28 PM

i would find it very difficult to live somewhere that you have to be quiet. very. difficult.
xo

Reply

3 Loukia March 16, 2010 at 5:32 PM

Elisa! What an awesome post my friend! And don’t be quiet just because of where you are! Be yourself! xoxox
.-= Loukia´s last blog ..This is the end, my friend… =-.

Reply

4 Jessica @ This is Worthwhile March 16, 2010 at 7:54 PM

Holy shit. I just realized that my husband has Swiss ancestry, direct, in fact, not guessed. This explains a LOT about him. I think he would be in HEAVEN there. When would be best for us to visit?? hahaha

And girl, I must have a whole lotta Italian buried in me somewhere under all this Irish because you just described me, too.
.-= Jessica @ This is Worthwhile´s last blog ..Deliberately vague =-.

Reply

5 Mwa March 16, 2010 at 7:58 PM

I did LOVE Zurich in summer. I’m sorry it’s being hard on you in Winter. As for being “too loud” – stuff them. Just stare back or ignore, but don’t let them dictate what you do, and above all don’t try to become less spontaneous/friendly/whatever. I see how that would happen, though – having moved back to Belgium, I’m having a hard time dealing with the reserved silences and am sometimes just not even trying any more.
.-= Mwa´s last blog ..I think I might be a nice-smelling troll =-.

Reply

6 Cafe Fashionista
Twitter:
March 16, 2010 at 10:10 PM

Don’t get me wrong, I love silence most of the time; but it’s kind of frightening after awhile. Speak out and break the silence, my love!! :)
.-= Cafe Fashionista´s last blog ..Tightwad Tuesday: Rag & Bone Tailrace Shirtdress for a Steal =-.

Reply

7 Holly March 16, 2010 at 10:19 PM

In college, I studied in Riva San Vitale, Switzerland — just a few miles to Chiasso, Italy. Crossing over into Italy was a wonderful walk or quick train ride — but I swear, it felt like you could hear the difference the minute you crossed the border! Even upscale Chiasso was more busy and bustling than Riva. So very very quiet and reserved and neat!

Reply

8 Slow Panic March 16, 2010 at 10:21 PM

Oh I wouldn’t last long at all. I am way way to loud. Just be yourself and they will learn to love you.
.-= Slow Panic´s last blog ..help me =-.

Reply

9 mountainmomma18 March 17, 2010 at 2:49 AM

Well crap that’s one more country I would just be the loud and obnoxious american. I mean I don’t go around chanting “USA, USA” or anything but I tend to laugh loudly and would go on and on about how awesome the place is to anyone who would listen. Screw it, I’ll tell them all I’m canadian.

Reply

10 Michelle April 3, 2010 at 2:33 PM

Your comment is too funny…i’m a Canadian; we are a bit shy, but not Swiss quiet ;-)

Reply

11 Denise @ Swelle March 17, 2010 at 12:26 PM

Aw, I love this post! And I am hugely relieved to know that I am not the only unwitting conversation killer out there! It’s my belief that if an intelligent and sensitive person isn’t aware of why their words may have been inappropriate in some way, then they simply weren’t!

You reminded me of when we lived in Paris last year and someone mentioned that Paris is ‘quieter’. We live in England and are Canadian. And after a week or so I did notice that the French are not loud. Not freakishly quiet but certainly more restrained – teenagers aren’t even obnoxious in the streets unless they’re tourists. This was proven every time there were American (or maybe even us polite Canadians!) tourists around, which was a lot as spring rolled in. I found myself making an effort to keep my own exuberance in check as I can be a bit loud as well (but never really thought of myself as such until then) and I’m quite animated when I tell as story (no apologies for that). I didn’t want to appear out of sync with the ways of the French and that’s probably because I love them so much. And there is something about the feel of Paris with all of its grand, quiet beauty that has a very serene effect if you connect with it.

But laughing out loud is wonderful. Silence is for funerals, libraries and ex-boyfriends. ♥♥
.-= Denise @ Swelle´s last blog ..The Outnet’s Massive 80-85% off Pop-Up Sale Starts Tomorrow! =-.

Reply

12 Gina March 17, 2010 at 2:20 PM

Oh my, between the quiet tram and the “proper” conversation, I would never survive. I’d be the loud, ugly American without a doubt.
.-= Gina´s last blog ..Playing Favorites =-.

Reply

13 melania March 17, 2010 at 3:00 PM

“That’s ok, it’s not like I was discussing state secrets.” – LOL

Thanks for this post. It clarifies something I’ve been struggling with. On average, I fall in the quiet category. However, I have been surrounded by vivacious people for most of my life. My mom loves to talk, most of my close friends love to talk, my future husband is a talker (thank god). NYC, my previous home, is full of great and awful noise. It’s ALIVE! If crickets exist, you don’t hear them. Before living in Zürich, I thought I would feel at home to be surrounded by quiet people. Instead, it’s depressing and can feel very lonely. Of course, I kept to myself during the harsh winter and that did not help. I just had not realized how much I relied on the energy of NYC. I really took it for granted. I’m ready for some loud, exuberant laughter!

Reply

14 Denise March 17, 2010 at 3:39 PM

I too would love to know what you said to quiet the entire table.

I am a louder person so I totally feel your pain! My trainee just complained that I yelled at her, which I didn’t. I think the problem is that I am loud, and it may have been taken as yelling. Although that would really be stretching it! Good luck with the quiet people!!!

Reply

15 jessica March 18, 2010 at 5:10 AM

wait, were you at that dinner too?
how about my swiss husband’s aunt is here visiting us in texas where we live now and the three of us are at the dinner table together in a completely and utterly silent house (sleeping infant) and i cannot HEAR WHAT THEY ARE SAYING because they talk so low. it is actually impossible, because we are less than a foot away from each other, but it is true. I think if any more swiss people came to dinner, we’d need a personal microphone system

Reply

16 AnnQ March 18, 2010 at 5:31 AM

That was an awesome post! I love how you told the woman on the Tram you weren’t discussing state secrets. LOL :-)
.-= AnnQ´s last blog ..600lb Woman trying to Gain Weight (yes, you read that right) =-.

Reply

17 Niki March 18, 2010 at 7:11 AM

thanks for stopping by! and i love that pic. xx
.-= Niki´s last blog ..It’s all in the details =-.

Reply

18 Jeanne ~ bermudabluez
Twitter:
March 18, 2010 at 9:36 AM

They would definitely throw me right out of that country! I’m not exactly q u i e t!!

So….what did you say at dinner???

Fabulous post girl!!
.-= Jeanne ~ bermudabluez´s last blog ..Spring….Bring It On! =-.

Reply

19 Lydia, Clueless Crafter March 18, 2010 at 6:16 PM

Alecia, I want to know too. What did you say??

I’m very familiar with killing a conversation. Mostly because I talk right over my dinner mate. So I guess you wouldn’t want me as your dinner partner;-)
.-= Lydia, Clueless Crafter´s last blog ..The Pampa in the Polis ~ Buenos Aires =-.

Reply

20 Keely March 18, 2010 at 6:16 PM

I like the idea of silence, but not ALL the time. Sometimes you need some animated conversation or thumpin’ music to get you going, y’know?

hang in there, just keep being you :)
.-= Keely´s last blog ..I had high hopes for that internship with Martha Stewart, too =-.

Reply

21 anne March 18, 2010 at 6:54 PM

Hi Elisa..Thank you so much for commenting on my blog..

It is surprising what you have to do in other cultures and countries. And even amongst friends. Sometimes happens to me too, I talk too much, or say the wrong things ooops!

Yes Port Isaac is a beautiful place, I went out of season, which is a good thing, it can be so overloaded with tourists, and I would imagine not a good place then as it is very small.

Reply

22 The Editor March 19, 2010 at 4:46 AM

Me…I would need some of that silver duct tape over my mouth in order to live there…I used to be quiet but my husband’s Italian ways have converted me…

Reply

23 paris (im)perfect March 19, 2010 at 11:20 AM

I can so relate to this! I have a really loud laugh (and I like to laugh often!), but it doesn’t go down so well in France. Sounds like Switzerland is even more harsh! Don’t give into it, girl. Live your life out loud! So glad you found my blog so I could discover yours! :)
-Sion
.-= paris (im)perfect´s last blog ..Faux Pas Friday: Madame Massage =-.

Reply

24 Brooke March 19, 2010 at 1:42 PM

last weekend my husband and i were going to hang out with people i don’t have a lot in common with – when i expressed concern about coversation pieces my hubby suggested i not speak unless i was spoken to. i laughed in his face.

i think you and i would get along very well :)
.-= Brooke´s last blog ..Our first fire! (and other random pictures) =-.

Reply

25 Carabee March 19, 2010 at 2:27 PM

While I think I would like the quiet, I suspect I’m actually louder than I realize. All that silence would make me uncomfortable. I’m too much of a fill the gaps with talking/laughter/singing type of person.
.-= Carabee´s last blog ..Sprung =-.

Reply

26 FROM THE RIGHT BANK March 19, 2010 at 4:17 PM

Hi, Elisa! The hubby was just talking about a business trip to Zurich and I thought of you then up popped your comment on my blog. :) I haven’t been to Switzerland in years and all I remember is how clean it was. But next time, I’m totally going to be looking to see how quiet it is. :) Have a great weekend!
.-= FROM THE RIGHT BANK´s last blog ..Style Shifts, Bohemian Interiors =-.

Reply

27 Andrea
Twitter:
March 19, 2010 at 5:33 PM

Honey, speak when you want to speak. Just do what you need to do and stay YOU. As a native NYer, wherever I am, I’m pretty d@mned loud. ;) And I’m not Italian, I’m Jewish! :P
.-= Andrea´s last blog ..Three Memes in One … =-.

Reply

28 Metropolitan Mum March 19, 2010 at 6:05 PM

Oh. My. God. Have you been living in my head??? I used to live in Lausanne, where no-one except the Ghanian exchange students would speak to me at University. I tried to join in conversations in between classes, only for people quickly replying to my question and then completely ignoring me.
I later moved to Zurich and made the exact same experiences you did on the tram. At the time I was having a long distance relationship with my now husband. Early morning on the tram was the only time we could have a conversation. I remember the train being packed, people rubbing their coats against each other, standing there in complete silence. I used to whisper and Big M couldn’t believe that I’d actually be on a train. I got lots and lots of lethal views.
We used to love the drinks at Kronenhalle, but I never got over the deafening silence in there. After a year I packed up and stopped the process of slowly dying from the inside.
Don’t get me wrong, there are things I love about Switzerland, and a few of my dearest friends are Swiss. But with all that silence around me, my inner voice just got louder and louder and wouldn’t stop screaming at me.

I am in London now. It’s a bit loud here ;-)
.-= Metropolitan Mum´s last blog ..Beauty on a budget: London’s best facials =-.

Reply

29 soccermom March 19, 2010 at 6:10 PM

I think I must be part Swiss and part Italian. Since I am very orderly, and very organized, but I have a big ( I mean huge)mouth. I am all about free speach!

Reply

30 Rebecca in Switzerland, xpatadventures.com March 20, 2010 at 10:10 AM

Thanks for the comment over on XpatAdventures! I love the name of your blog. Before I moved to Lugano, I never would have globetrotted in heels. You know, comfort all American was more my style. Now it’s all heels, all the time. The trick is finding comfortable ones! Love your blog! See you at BlogHer? I’d proposed an expat panel but never heard back… blogging has completely changed the expat experience, hasn’t it?
Ciao bella da Lugano.
Rebecca
.-= Rebecca in Switzerland, xpatadventures.com´s last blog ..Looking all Lion King in his winter coat =-.

Reply

31 Krystal March 20, 2010 at 5:36 PM

You have an absolutely lovely blog! Can’t wait to read more :)

Reply

32 MrShev March 20, 2010 at 7:35 PM

You’ve The Gone-Away World.

Rock star.

Anyway, loving the blog – working my way backwards. Thanks for the lovely comment, if you do make me prime minister then I will invert the Swiss flag and invade the rest of Europe in a fleet of ambulances.

Reply

33 MrShev March 20, 2010 at 7:36 PM

READ should be in between You’ve and The Gone Away World.
.-= MrShev´s last blog ..Little Literature =-.

Reply

34 Pres. Kathy March 20, 2010 at 8:33 PM

Amazing post! This is why I love your blog so much!
.-= Pres. Kathy´s last blog ..Some projects I have been working on =-.

Reply

35 Nicole March 21, 2010 at 2:02 AM

I like it that quite after 9 pm at my house. If you lived here in Chicago we wouldn’t shush you at all. All long as we visually see you phone in your hand. Otherwise I’d think you were talking to yourself.
.-= Nicole´s last blog ..WTFlashback {When I first started blogging} =-.

Reply

36 Michelle April 3, 2010 at 2:46 PM

Wow,
Great post!
I would certainly go bonkers in an environment like that and I’m considered the quite one in my family. I now understand why I clicked so well when I visited Italy.

Reply

Previous post:

Next post:

Copyright Elisa Bieg, 2008-2009.